Showing posts with label Star Wars Rebels. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Star Wars Rebels. Show all posts

Friday, June 24, 2022

Episode Rankings: Star Wars Rebels

As a followup to Star Wars: The Clone Wars, Rebels is an alright show, though much more flawed. It has a slow first season and a shaky ending, as well as an irritating protagonist. However, it also tells a strong serailized story with a generally likable cast and boasts some of the best moments in all of Star Wars, so I'd say it's still very much worth watching if you're a fan of the franchise. Here's my ranking of its episodes:

  1. Trials Of The Darksaber (S3.15)
  2. Twilight Of The Apprentice: Part 2 (S2.22)
  3. Family Reunion And Farewell (S4.15)
  4. Twin Suns (S3.20)
  5. Twilight Of The Apprentice: Part 1 (S2.21)
  6. The Siege Of Lothal: Part 2 (S2.02)
  7. Jedi Night (S4.10)
  8. Legacy Of Mandalore (S3.16)
  9. Shroud Of Darkness (S2.18)
  10. Fire Across The Galaxy (S1.15)
  11. The Last Battle (S3.06)
  12. Zero Hour: Part 1 (S3.21)
  13. The Siege Of Lothal: Part 1 (S2.01)
  14. The Future Of The Force (S2.10)
  15. A World Between Worlds (S4.14)
  16. Call To Action (S1.13)
  17. The Honorable Ones (S2.17)
  18. Zero Hour: Part 2 (S3.22)
  19. DUME (S4.11)
  20. Always Two There Are (S2.05)
  21. The Holocrons Of Fate (S3.03)
  22. Through Imperial Eyes (S3.17)
  23. Vision Of Hope (S1.12)
  24. The Lost Commanders (S2.03)
  25. Visions And Voices (S3.11)
  26. Rebel Resolve (S1.14)
  27. Blood Sisters (S2.08)
  28. A Fool's Hope (S4.14)
  29. Path Of The Jedi (S1.10)
  30. Rebel Assault (S4.09)
  31. An Inside Man (S3.10)
  32. The Protector Of Concord Dawn (S2.13)
  33. Legacy (S2.11)
  34. Rise Of The Old Masters (S1.05)
  35. Heroes Of Mandalore: Part 2 (S4.02)
  36. Steps Into Shadow: Part 2 (S3.02)
  37. Relics Of The Old Republic (S2.04)
  38. Stealth Strike (S2.09)
  39. Hera's Heroes (S3.05)
  40. Gathering Forces (S1.09)
  41. The Occupation (S4.05)
  42. The Mystery Of Chopper Base (S2.20)
  43. Steps Into Shadow: Part 1 (S3.01)
  44. A Princess On Lothal (S2.12)
  45. In The Name Of The Rebellion: Part 1 (S4.03)
  46. Ghosts Of Geonosis: Part 2 (S3.13)
  47. Wolves And A Door (S4.12)
  48. Imperial Supercommandos (S3.07)
  49. Breaking Ranks (S1.06)
  50. Secret Cargo (S3.18)
  51. Legends Of The Lasat (S2.14)
  52. Kindred (S4.07)
  53. Empire Day (S1.08)
  54. Heroes Of Mandalore: Part 1 (S4.01)
  55. Homecoming (S2.16)
  56. The Antilles Extraction (S3.04)
  57. Wings Of The Master (S2.07)
  58. In The Name Of The Rebellion: Part 2 (S4.04)
  59. Ghosts Of Geonosis: Part 1 (S3.12)
  60. Idiot's Array (S1.11)
  61. Spark Of Rebellion: Part 2 (S1.02)
  62. The Wynkahthu Job (S3.09)
  63. Warhead (S3.14)
  64. Out Of Darkness (S1.07)
  65. Flight Of The Defender (S4.06)
  66. Brothers Of The Broken Horn (S2.06)
  67. Crawler Commanders (S4.08)
  68. Droids In Distress (S1.03)
  69. The Forgotten Droid (S2.19)
  70. Iron Squadron (S3.08)
  71. Spark Of Rebellion: Part 1 (S1.01)
  72. Double Agent Droid (S3.19)
  73. The Call (S2.15)
  74. Fighter Flight (S1.04)

Sunday, August 8, 2021

Star Wars Rebels (Season 4)

Star Wars Rebels has a really messy series, with high highs and low lows. So it only seems natural that it gets a final season that works for the series on some levels and feels a bit baffling on other levels.

Unlike the last two seasons, Season 4 is focused on a single storyline, with the main cast of rebels returning to Lothal in an attempt to save it on their own. Despite seeing them spend their time with the larger rebellion these last two seasons, I think it feels right for them to return to where it all began after all of their development and growth, and I actually really liked "The Occupation", which had them adjust to the empire-occupied Lothal. The focused storyline also allows for a season that's even more tightly-knit than the first, while having the much stronger writing and characters of the latter seasons. There were hardly any standalone episodes this time around, resulting in a serialized affair that feels surprisingly like a slow burn storyline. After the first two episodes tie up loose ends from Season 3, the rebels head over to Lothal and spend some time acclimating and planning out their assault. While this does mean the first half is a bit weaker, it also means that all of the plot points set-up in the first half get paid off in the much more dramatic, fast-paced, and exciting second half. And what a second half! The end of Rebels packs in so many hugely important and impactful moments like Kanan's death, Ahsoka's return, and Ezra's plan in the finale that really makes it feel like this is the end.

However, this is Rebels, so I predictably have a few big issues with the season. While I already mentioned that the first half was a bit slow, even in the generally good second half, there are some plot directions that really rubbed me the wrong way, mostly because of contrivances that even I noticed (these types of things usually don't bother me). For example, why didn't Ezra use the Purgil against the empire years ago? And how did Hera and Kanan have a kid in such a short span of time? Or why was Ahsoka so important to save if she didn't do anything in the final battle? But while most of these questions aren't that big of a deal, I need to talk about The World Between Worlds for a second. It's a time travel mechanic set up after an entire season's worth of dull Lothwolf scenes, yet it's only used once to save Ahsoka before never being mentioned again in all of Star Wars. It feels like the writers didn't know how Ahsoka could escape her fight with Vader, so they just invented time travel to save her without realizing the ramifications. I wish this wasn't that big of an issue, but so much of the season is focused on setting-up what ends up feeling like a deus ex machina, ultimately dragging down Season 4 quite a bit for me.

Still, the second half was a solid ending to the series, and it had some generally good episodes:

Jedi Night: Look, Kanan had a ton of death flags this episode, his sacrifice was very much predictable. However, I think Jedi Night was a fantastic sendoff to the character and easily one of the best episodes of the season. Kanan helping Hera escape was a lot of fun, and it gave us plenty of time to see the two of them together, and Kanan's big sacrifice at the end was incredibly impactful. 

DUME: I didn't care much about the Lothwolves stuff, but otherwise, I loved how the entire episode was about the Rebels dealing with the grief over Kanan's death. There were a lot of great individual moments, like Sabine and Zeb realizing that Kanan stopped the TIE Defenders, Chopper comforting Hera, the Ruhk fight, even Ezra being consoled by the giant wolf, I found it all incredibly emotional.   

World Between Worlds: While I have my complaints about the World Between Worlds, I do have to give credit to just how much of an audiovisual treat this episode was. The 2D black-and-white lineart looks fantastically trippy, the Jedi voices heard in the void were peak fanservice, and the big escape from Palpatine was pretty cool. I also liked Sabine's interrogation with the creepy Minister Hydan.

Family Reunion And Farewell: Aside from the Purgill reveal (which was admittedly kinda cool), this was a really great finale that definitely did right by the characters. It was tense, action-packed, and immensely rewarding. The big battle with Thrawn's fleet gave most of the cast something to do (even minor characters like Mulch and Gregor), Palpatine was implemented in a realistic and threatening manner, Ezra's sacrifice was pretty great, and the timeskip at the end was a nice bittersweet farewell to the cast. With all my gripes with the season, I think this was a strong ending for the series.

Overall, this final season of Rebels was a bit messy, with a slow start and plenty of contrivances near its end. However, I think it did the characters right, brought the conflict full circle, and packed in plenty of impactful episodes and moments in its second half.

3/5 Stars


My ranking of the Star Wars Rebels seasons is:

2 > 3 > 4 > 1

My ranking of the Star Wars Rebels finales is:

2 > 4 > 1 > 3

Favorite Episode: Trials Of The Darksaber

And finally, between Clone Wars and Rebels, I think I preferred the former. The anthology structure of Clone Wars meant that the quality of each arc was a bit of a crapshoot, but it also meant we'd get long stretches of amazing episodes, culminating in the amazing Siege Of Mandalore. I also liked the animation style better as well as everything involving the clones. On the other hand, while I preferred the serialized nature of Rebels and liked being able to focus on a small group of characters, the show was still a bit of a flawed mess, managing to be just as uneven as Clone Wars, while also having Ezra hijack nearly every single episode. I enjoyed both series and I could easily call them great, but if I had to choose, Clone Wars wins out.

Thursday, August 5, 2021

Star Wars Rebels (Season 3)

Season 2 of Star Wars Rebels was a big improvement on the previous season, fixing most of my issues and making me like most of the characters. Season 3 does a solid job of keeping up the momentum, even if it ends up being a bit messy.

Unlike Season 2, this season has a lot of storylines, all interweaving throughout the season. The main story arc is about the rebels slowly growing their ranks by traveling the galaxy in search of anyone who can join, while planning an assault to take back Lothal. This storyline is fine, though a bit frustrating when the main cast loses all their progress by the finale, but the real highlight is the villain, Thrawn. A carry-over from the decanonized EU, Thrawn is a terrifying antagonist whose manages to prove his intelligence multiple times throughout the season, especially when it comes to his discovery that Kallus has now turncoated. Speaking of which, this season helped me buy Kallus changing sides way more. Meanwhile, Maul wants to use the Holocrons to find and get his revenge on Obi-Wan. I think Maul is also really threatening this season as he becomes really unhinged, and his final showdown with Obi-Wan is an excellent scene. But the biggest highlight of the season is Sabine, who became hands-down my favorite character in the series. Keeping up the trend of amazing storylines about Mandalore, Sabine finding the Darksaber and having to learn to use it, confront her inner demons, return to Mandalore, and reunite with her family isn't just the highlight of the series, it's the highlight of Rebels as a whole and some of the best Star Wars ever made.

However, I think this season might be a bit too overstuffed, as the show still has to balance between all of its story arcs and the many standalone episodes that are still being implemented. As a result, some storylines don't get too much time, even worse considering they are the most interesting of the bunch: Maul only appears in three episodes throughout the season, Sabine's Mandalore arc is just two episodes, and Thrawn doesn't appear nearly as much as I would've wished (thankfully, he's still around for Season 4). I also found that the amount of character-driven episodes this season weren't nearly as much compared to last time, as many of the episodes were more focused on the recruitment storyline. Thankfully, this is more of an issue in the first half of the season. The second half is far more plot-heavy, but even it has its low points (Double Agent Droid, especially). The final issue I had this season, and probably the most frustrating one, is Ezra, who I still don't quite like. His snarky attitude continues to undercut otherwise emotional moments, but what makes him especially bad this season is the fact that he appears everywhere. Trials Of The Darksaber, Through Imperial Eyes, and Twin Suns are fantastic episodes that are focused around a single person (Sabine, Kallus, and Maul respectively), but Ezra has to play a pretty sizable role in all of them. I know it seems like Ezra needs the most screentime since he's technically the protagonist, but it feels like he steals attention from all the other (and better) characters.

At its best, Season 3 had some phenomenal episodes, especially in its second half:

The Last Battle: This episode was just plain cute. It's a heartwarming resolution to the Clone Wars that has the remaining clones and droids finally make amends and realize they're on the same side. It's a love letter to the series that came before Rebels, and was just such a pleasant watch.

Trials Of The Darksaber: What a perfect episode. Right from the get-go, I knew something was different with this one. The music was somber, the pace was slow, and we got a beautifully animated (yeah, I said it) shadow play detailing the history of the Darksaber. The main storyline is just about Kanan teaching Sabine how to wield the Darksaber, with no subplots or fluff. There's an uncomfortable buildup as she continues to bury the reason she left her family from Kanan, the viewers, and herself, all culminating in that phenomenal final fight where Sabine finally lets loose. It's a powerful moment of catharsis, Tiya Sircar's voice acting is amazing, the score is beautiful, and even Ezra shuts up for a bit. Easily the best episode of the series and rivaling The Phantom Apprentice as one of the best Star Wars TV episodes.

Legacy Of Mandalore: While it doesn't quite live up to Trials Of The Darksaber, this was another strong Mandalore-centric episode that ends up feeling as emotional as it is because of what we learned about Sabine. Seeing her reunite with her family is a really compelling storyline since the empire put both sides in a really difficult situation, and the final fight with Saxon was excellent, from Sabine wielding Ezra's lightsaber, to her mom shooting Saxon for her. I also really liked that Sabine doesn't think she deserves the Darksaber, so she decides to stay behind and give it to someone who does.

Twin Suns: The final seven-or-so minutes of this episode was excellent. It was great to see Obi-Wan Kenobi again, the final scene with Luke was fantastic, and that lightsaber fight! It's such a gutsy move, a fight that ends in only three strikes, but I wouldn't call it anti-climactic. It's packed with symbolism and call backs, references to Star Wars's inspirations, loaded dialogue, and watching Obi-Wan and Darth Maul switch poses to plan for the fight is as tense as any actual lightsaber fight. That ending was so good it makes you forget how much of the episode was just Ezra bumbling around in the desert. 

Zero Hour: While it doesn't feel as grand and climactic as the prior two season finales,  Zero Hour feels ambitious in its own way, depicting a pretty large scale space battle filled with strategy. If anything, it's one of the most war-like entries in the Star Wars franchise. There are also a lot of great individual moments like Sato's sacrifice, Kallus escaping Thrawn, and Sabine coming in with the Mandalorians to save the day.

Overall, the third season of Star Wars Rebels is a bit more of a mess than the previous season, with high highs and low lows, but it has a strong second half and some of the best episodes in the series.

3/5 Stars

Tuesday, August 3, 2021

Star Wars Rebels (Season 2)

I didn't like the first season of Star Wars Rebels. Between the writing, characters, and general tone, it all just felt off to the point where I had difficulty truly caring. Season 2, on the other hand, was not just an improvement. It was a genuinely strong season that fixed nearly all of my issues with the show.

Season 2 of Star Wars Rebels starts with a massive change to the series. The Rebels are now working with Ahsoka and the rest of the Rebellion, Darth Vader (who Ahsoka now knows is Anakin) has summoned two more Inquisitors after them, the Empire has tightened its grip on Lothal so much that the Rebels can't stay there anymore, and Captain Rex has joined the team. It's a lot of changes in only a few episodes, but it helps to widen the scope of the series by putting the main characters into a conflict far greater than themselves. However, outside of this big status quo shift, this season doesn't have quite as much of a tightly-woven plot as the first, as it's mostly a build towards Ahsoka's confrontation with Vader. The two new Inquisitors are cool with neat designs, but even they don't appear too often. However, most of the standalone episodes that comprise this season were actually really enjoyable, as nearly all of them focus on the characters and progress their individual arcs, while also giving screentime to unlikely pairings within the cast (Rex and Kanan, Kanan and Sabine, Zeb and Kallus). Don't get me wrong, I think there were a bunch of episodes that felt like padding and the season must have been hell to watch live, but I found storylines like Zeb meeting other Lasats, Hera reuniting with her father, Sabine meeting an old bounty hunter friend, and Ezra learning the truth about his parents to be nearly as compelling as the main cast.

Right from the first episode, it felt like Season 2 of Rebels fixed some of my greatest issues with the character dynamics by just increasing the stakes. There was no time to mess around on Lothal and get into petty arguments, the main team not only got a chance to explore more planets and meet more characters, but they were put in danger far more regularly and got the chance to really show how much they care about each other. Even more, thanks to the aforementioned unlikely pairings, the main cast feels more tightly-knit, and dare I say it, like a family. It helps that they don't bicker nearly as much as last season, and it all leads to me buying their chemistry so much more. I've also started to like a lot of the individual characters better as well. I still found Ezra's cocky attitude a bit annoying, but the plot thread about his flirting with the dark side adds an interesting element to his character. Zeb was a surprising highlight, as his constantly being out of his league with the Jedi and Sith made him oddly endearing. Hera finally got some episodes to herself, Kanan bonding with Rex led to some great character development, and Sabine continues to be pretty badass. And the returning characters were awesome too, seeing Ahsoka, Rex, and Darth Maul again was welcome without feeling too fanservice-y.

Unlike last season, there are far more episodes than the finale that I'd consider highlights:

Siege Of Lothal: This jam-packed and shocking season premiere set the tone and stakes for the season, as the promises of Season 1's finale are immediately fulfilled with Darth Vader's harrowing fight with the Rebels, Minister Tua's surprisingly heartrending death, the devastating fate of Lothal and the Phoenix Squadron, and biggest of all, the scene where Ahsoka learns who Vader really is.

Always Two There Are: The two Inquisitors made one hell of a first appearance in this horror-inspired episode that forces Ezra, Sabine, and Zeb to fend against them in an abandoned hospital. It's suspenseful, exciting, and it was the episode to make me really like Zeb, as his rescue attempt at the end of the episode showed a surprising amount of resourcefulness.

The Future Of The Force: This isn't the only episode where the cast has to save some force-sensitive babies (Clone Wars did the same thing), and it's not the only episode where they're on the run from Inquisitors, but I think this is the best-executed instance of both storylines. It's a tense, action-packed chase that constantly puts Ezra, Kanan, and Zeb at a disadvantage, only for Ahsoka to appear and turn the tables at the end in very spectacular fashion.

The Honorable Ones: This episode was a weird one, trapping Zeb and Kallas on an ice planet together and forcing them to team up and escape. Their dynamic was entertaining and fun, seeing them work together at the end was great, and I like how they ended up gaining a respect for each other. I'm not quite sure how I feel about Kallus turning against the empire since I don't think he deserves a redemption arc, but on its own merits, I really liked this one. 

Shroud Of Darkness: Odd designs of Anakin and Yoda aside, this was a fantastic episode and a strong set-up for the finale. The trip to the Jedi Temple led to a ton of massive revelations, like the fact that the Jedi Council was plagued by the dark side, that Ezra has to go to Malachor, and that the Grand Inquisitor was a Jedi knight (and so is Kanan now). And now that the empire knows of the Lothal Jedi temple, it seems the Rebels may never be allowed to go back.

Twilight Of The Apprentice: Easily the most iconic episode of the series, this is a phenomenal finale that rivals some of the best Clone Wars episodes. Ezra teaming up with Darth Maul was such a cool concept and a genius way to get him closer to the dark side, Ahsoka's battle with Darth Vader was as fun as it was emotionally-charged, and the insane ending serves as one hell of a cliffhanger. But that's not to discredit the rest of the episode, which is dark, intense, ambitious, and shocking.

Overall, Season 2 of Star Wars Rebels is great. It widens the scope, increases the stakes, fleshes out the characters and their dynamics, and despite its fairly minimal plot, ends on a fantastic note.

4/5 Stars

Saturday, July 31, 2021

Star Wars Rebels (Season 1)

Given how much I like Clone Wars and Star Wars as a whole, it's surprising that I haven't seen Star Wars Rebels yet. With Bad Batch airing with multiple episodes focused on characters from the series, it's about time I finally give it a watch.

Star Wars Rebels is a sequel series to Clone Wars about a tag team of rebels during the rise of the empire. The team is composed of Twi'lek pilot Hera, secret Jedi Kanan, brawny Lasat Zeb, artsy Mandalorian Sabine, faulty droid Chopper, and newly-joined Padawan Ezra. This season has the rebels try to gain minor victories against the empire while evading the Jedi-killing Inquisitor. On its own merits, I think this really works as a storyline for this first season. The Inquisitor is a terrifying force whenever he's on screen, and there's a surprisingly tight sense of continuity this season, with plot points from earlier episodes like the Gall Treyvus transmissions, FULCRUM, and Vizago paying off in the final few episodes. Having only 14 episodes this season definitely helped compared to other Star Wars series, the pacing is pretty much perfect this season. The final few episodes are a particular highlight, with the arrival of Tarkin signaling the point that I really started to enjoy the series. However, there's a big problem with Star Wars Rebels that's preventing me from loving it right now, and that's the fact that I just don't like most of the cast.

For starters, this season is almost entirely focused on the protagonist Ezra despite being based around an entire ensemble cast. While the backstory about his parents is interesting enough, I think he's too much of a jerk to the rest of the cast for me to really care about him. I feel like that applies to the cast as a whole, though, they're bickering and fighting so often throughout the season that it's hard for me to buy into the fact that they're the "family" they say they are. And while characters like Zeb, Hera, and Sabine have a lot of potential with their interesting pasts that are hinted at throughout the season, they barely get any screentime. I'm also not a big fan of the art style, especially in comparison to Clone Wars. While I'm all for exaggerated and cartoonish movement (I loved the art of Tartakovsky's Clone Wars), it's oddly distracting in Rebels. It's probably because of how the characters are always moving, constantly, even when they're talking to each other. I also don't love how simplistic the character designs are, especially when it comes to returning cast members like Obi-Wan and Ahsoka in the finale. On the other hand, I loved the score. Kevin Kiner returns from Clone Wars, and while the music doesn't have quite as many memorable individual pieces as that series, the background music as a whole perfectly evokes the vibe of the original trilogy. 

Despite my many gripes with the season, the final few episodes were pretty great:

Vision Of Hope: For the first time in Rebels, I feel like I genuinely get the sense that fighting the empire can feel genuinely hopeless. Gall Treyvus was a sign of hope from the start of the season, so the reveal that he's an empire plant is really effective and crushing. It's a low point for the cast this season that solidifies how alone they are.

Call To Action: Tarkin's arrival to Star Wars Rebels was such a great idea to finally establish the stakes. He's such a no-nonsense character and he makes it clear from his very first scene. Aside from his appearance, though, Call To Action has the main cast make their very first large-scale impact on the galaxy with their transmission message, along with Kanan's capture setting up for the season to end.

Fire Across The Galaxy: This was a pretty great finale. The final lightsaber fight with the Grand Inquisitor was great, most of the cast had some moment to shine, and the last few minutes were excellent. The reveal of the Rebellion widens the scale for the series, and the appearances of Ahsoka and Darth Vader left me (and I'm sure many other fans) very excited for Season 2.

Overall, the first season of Star Wars Rebels is well-paced enough and has a strong ending, but the generally unlikable and thin cast and off-putting animation prevents me from truly loving the series, at least right now.

2/5 Stars