Showing posts with label March Comes In Like A Lion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label March Comes In Like A Lion. Show all posts

Saturday, June 18, 2022

Episode Rankings: March Comes In Like A Lion

March Comes In Like A Lion is definitely a good anime, with stunning visuals, likable characters, and a premise that should have right up my alley, but it didn't really grab me as much as I had hoped it would. 3gatsu No Lion is split right down the middle between things I am interested in (the Kawamoto sisters, Kyouko) and things I'm not interested in (Shoji, the flashbacks), so it had me absolutely engrossed one minute and bored out of my mind the next. That bullying arc was absolute fire though, I'll give the show that. Here's my ranking of its episodes:

  1. Ladybug Bush/Feelings (S2.04)
  2. Black Mist/Light (S2.12)
  3. Small Palm/Sunny Place (S2.13)
  4. The Other House/Child Of March Town (S2.22)
  5. Silver Thread/Water's Surface/Base Of The Blue Nigh (S1.17)
  6. Feelings/Confession (S2.05)
  7. Something Given (S1.10)
  8. Kyoto (S1.20)
  9. Kingdom (S2.09)
  10. Being Here/Summer Vacation (S2.19)
  11. Image/Distant Thunder (S1.08)
  12. Passing Time/Spring Comes (S2.21)
  13. Blinding Darkness/Just A Little Water (S1.14)
  14. Small World/Letter (S2.06)
  15. Over The Cuckoo's Nest (S1.05)
  16. Burnt Field: Part 2 (S2.18)
  17. Distant Thunder (S1.09)
  18. June/Ladybug Bush (S2.03)
  19. Beyond The Night Sky (S1.03)
  20. White Storm (S2.15)
  21. Teach Me How To Play Shogi (S1.07)
  22. Summer Vacation/New Year (S2.20)
  23. Setting Sun/Ramune (S2.01)
  24. Torrent/Passing Time (S1.18)
  25. New School Term/Fighter (S1.22)
  26. Start Of The Rainy Season/Hachiya (S2.07)
  27. Black River/Beyond The Door (S1.13)
  28. Beyond The Bridge (S1.02)
  29. Where The Sun Shines/Small World (S2.11)
  30. Passing The Night/Kyoto (S1.19)
  31. White Storm/Restart (S2.16)
  32. The Old Year/The New Year (S1.11)
  33. Flowing Away/White Storm (S2.14)
  34. When The Cherry Blossoms Bloom/Small Murmur (S1.21)
  35. Chaos/Kumakura (S2.02)
  36. Moonlight/Lump Of Ego (S1.15)
  37. Burnt Field: Part 1 (S2.17)
  38. The Town Along The River (S1.01)
  39. Midday Moon/Adventurers (S2.08)
  40. What Lies On The Opposite Shore/Black River (S1.12)
  41. Silver Wings/River Scenery (S2.10)
  42. Running Through The Night/Middle Of The Slope (S1.16)
  43. Child Of God (S1.06)
  44. VS (S1.04)

Monday, August 16, 2021

March Comes In Like A Lion (Season 2)

The first season of March Comes In Like A Lion was definitely enjoyable, but it never really blew me away. Its second season, on the other hand, manages to reach some incredible heights in both its presentation and dramatic writing.

The first half of Season 2 of 3gatsu No Lion is probably the best streak of episodes in the entire series, briefly shifting focus to Hinata as she has to deal with bullying in school. This entire storyline is so unbelievably compelling, mostly because of how realistically the anime deals with its subject matter. The show explores how truly difficult bullying can be to stop due to teachers and students who pretend nothing happened to prevent making a scene, along with parents who refuse to admit their kids did nothing wrong. Not only is the bullying that Hinata receives never played for laughs, but the show treats it with such seriousness that the scenes end up being scarier than most horror movies/shows I've seen. As much as I love A Silent Voice's more idealistic treatment of the subject matter, I think this show does it better. It helps that Hinata is a strong and proactive protagonist, bolstered by Kana Hanazawa's amazing performance. I also really like that Rei and Akari get their own character arcs around Hinata's situation, the former wanting to return the favor for taking him in, and the latter being worried she's not a good enough caretaker for her sister. Even the shoji storyline throughout this first half is pretty alright, as I really wanted to see Rei win the Rookie Tournament to support himself and the sisters.

Once the bullying arc ends, however, the second half of the season isn't quite able to stack up. Once again, I think the shoji stuff this season is far more interesting than in Season 1. Being able to learn more about the mysterious Souya was great and the Burnt Field arc is pretty visually stunning (I also really like the running gag of the poorly-composited shoji game posters), but it still doesn't grip me as much as Rei's personal life and the Kawamoto sisters. Thankfully, the final few episodes do a really good job of bringing all of the character arcs and plot threads together in the end. On the other hand, I think some characters got a bit shafted (no pun intended) this time around. I was totally fine with Harunobu being bed-ridden for a large portion of the season since I never really liked him, but the Shoji-Science Club definitely didn't appear enough given how important they are for Rei's social life. I was also really disappointed that Kyoko barely appeared at all throughout the season. She's such a fascinating character and having her meet the Kawamoto sisters near the end of Season 1 could have led to so many interesting storylines and dynamics, so not seeing her was a bit of a shame. As for the presentation, 3gatsu No Lion looks even better than Season 1, especially when it comes to the lighting. As I previously mentioned, the Burnt Field episodes look absolutely stunning.

Unlike Season 1, this season had episodes that could rank among the best I've seen in an anime, such as:

Ladybug Bush/Feelings: This was the episode of 3gatsu No Lion for me. It was such a massive jump in quality from the rest of the series before it, kickstarting the season's best arc and shifting a large portion of the focus to Hinata. The whole episode was just heartbreaking, from what happened to Chiho, to Hina's breakdown by the river, to the fact that everyone just tries to ignore the bullying going on in Hina's school, to the brief shift to Hinata's narration. But I think the most affecting thing about this episode was Rei himself. I think it's perfect that, after being bullied at school himself, Rei would be the one to try to support and help Hinata now that his own life has taken a turn for the better. And that line from him, "You are my lifesaver" absolutely broke me.

Black Mist/Light: This episode was the point where the "bullying arc" comes to a head. That opening scene where Hinata confronts Takagi (the bully) in the homeroom was just so intense and anxiety-inducing. I really like the new replacement teacher for his calm and reasonable attitude, even with Takagi's mom pressuring Akari about "proof". I especially liked how the animation had a darker hue for most of the episode except for the ending where Hinata was comforting Akari.

Small Palm/Sunny Place: Coming after all the pain Hinata had to go through, this episode was an incredibly heartwarming end to the bullying arc. I think Chiho's letter was the highlight here, it was really satisfying to learn about how she's recovering. I also thought the ending with Rei and Hinata was a nice parallel to Ladybug Bush/Feelings, though with a much happier tone to it.

The Other House/Child Of March Town: This was a really good finale for the season. It ties up plenty of loose ends with Takahashi leaving and Rei moving up a class, and the final scene of Hinata getting a bob cut is entertaining, but the real highlight is Rei briefly reuniting with his mom, giving us some of the few family drama in the season.

Overall, while the bullying arc may have taken most of the spotlight for me and some characters were a bit shafted, I think this second season is overall a much stronger outing for the series with its improved visuals and stronger emotional impact.

4/5 Stars

Tuesday, August 10, 2021

March Comes In Like A Lion (Season 1)

March Comes In Like A Lion (which I'll call 3gatsu No Lion for the sake of shortening it) is a fairly slow-paced character study about a high school shogi player with amazing atmosphere and characters but some pretty boring stretches at times.

3gatsu No Lion is an anime about a professional shogi player named Rei Kiriyama who, despite being a high schooler, moved away from his adoptive family and lives on his own. He's haunted by his pretty traumatic past and his shogi skills are starting to slip, but he's also been taken in by a small family of three sisters who care for him far more than his original adoptive family ever did. There isn't much of a "plot" to this one, it's really about Rei navigating life, coping with his past, learning to make friends, and making a better future for himself. While this could make the series feel pretty aimless for some people, that's not entirely a problem for me. I love shows where nothing happens and you get to just follow the characters through their lives, K-On's one of my favorite anime of all time. However, given how many aspects are at play in Rei's life, I definitely find certain subplots more interesting than others. For example, I was incredibly invested in Rei's relationship with the Kawamoto sisters along with his encounters with his adoptive family, but the shogi games were a bit of a bore for me (this is no Queen's Gambit, to put it simply). While I'm sure other people might feel differently, it meant that certain episodes would end up being far more enjoyable than others. I also think the anime gets off to a bit of a slow start since the first few episodes prioritize flashbacks to Rei's past over character interaction, but that all changes once Kyouko shows up in the present day.

Without much of a plot, 3gatsu No Lion is purely character-driven, so it's a good thing I like most of the characters, or at least find them interesting. Obviously, Rei is a incredibly complex protagonist with such a twisted past and his many issues. The series does an amazing job of depicting his depression in a realistic manner, like how he doesn't seem too bad when interacting until he's on his own and he starts to reflect. The three Kawamoto sisters are also incredibly lovable, though not quite as complex (especially the little one Momo). They're a real positive force in the series that just makes the general tone more upbeat by being on screen. Kyouko is probably my favorite character, though, and easily the most fascinating. She perfectly toes the line between sympathetic due to her childhood of neglect and abandonment, and detestable for the abuse she inflicts on Rei. She doesn't appear too often, but makes a big impact every time she does, partly helped by the fact that she always gets some really fluid animation. The only character I found myself not quite loving is Harunobu, who gets some funny and emotional moments but is also kind of annoying at times whenever he's stuck in the role of comic relief. Outside of him, though, I think the comedy of 3gatsu No Lion is generally pretty good. I tend to laugh whenever the Kawamoto sisters are involved, and the show never undercuts any of its drama with the humor. Frankly, I think this anime does a good job of juggling tone and pacing without feeling disjointed or losing any of its impact.

The first thing that really stuck out to me about 3gatsu No Lion is the animation, done by Studio SHAFT of Madoka fame. The more of their stuff I watch, the more SHAFT's style has been becoming one of my personal favorites, between the sketchy hand-drawn characters, the stunning backgrounds, and the frequent art shifts. This anime in particular uses a beautiful painterly style for the backgrounds that just looks stunning, and the facial expressions do a really good job of emulating the look of the manga. While I never brought this up in my Madoka review, I've always been impressed how consistently fluid SHAFT's works look. None of the character movements are stiff at all, the hair moves in the wind, it really doesn't feel like many shortcuts are taken at all. I also adore the sound design, especially when it comes to the comedy. The vocal sound effects almost always elicits a laugh out of me, every single time. The voice acting is pretty great too, which is solid all around but especially great in the emotional scenes. The music is probably the least impressive aspect of the anime's presentation, as it's a bit subdued and low-key, but it does a solid job of setting the tone for the series. As a whole, though, I think 3gatsu No Lion has some pretty stunning presentation, like most of Shaft's work.

This season was so consistently solid that it's hard to truly find which episodes were worse than others. However, there were two highlights worth noting: 

Something Given: Rei doesn't let out his emotions too often, so the ending of Something Given was a bit of a shock. Kyouko's manipulations and the pettiness from his opponents finally got to him, resulting in a devastating breakdown that I'd call the most emotional moment of the season.

Silver Thread/Water's Surface/Base Of The Blue Night: Seeing the Kawamoto sisters and Kyouko finally meet was a pretty new deal, the intersection of Rei's past and present day. The second half of the episode had a pretty strong balance of drama and humor, between Rei and Kyouko's pretty intense fight and Hinata's immediate hatred for Kyouko, and Momo's hilariously sudden appearance and Kyouko's false belief that Rei liked one of the sisters.

Kyoto: I wasn't the biggest fan of Shimada's storyline throughout the season, but this episode was a pretty powerful ending, one might argue it's the climactic moment of the entire season. Shimada was so close to winning if he didn't have that tunnel vision, but Rei wasn't able to tell him. It's a pretty gutsy and painful route to take, but that's why I was impressed they took it.

Overall, 3gatsu No Lion gets its characters right and has the great visuals you'd expect from a SHAFT production, but it had a bit of a slow part and none of the shogi storylines really hooked me, a problem since this was half the series.

3/5 Stars